As for 'saving' the Lower Lakes, the Coorong and Murray Mouth, this is not dependent on how much water is sent across the border into South Australia. These problems are a result of human intervention.
Lake Alexandrina and Lake Albert, known as the Lower Lakes, were originally a mixture of salty water from the sea and fresh water from the Murray, in common with all the other estuaries in Australia. However, in the 1930s five barrages were erected to prevent the entry of the sea, keeping them artificially fresh. These barrages prevent tidal flows from keeping the Murray mouth open, which has become heavily silted.
Moreover, beginning more than a century ago, South Australia converted huge areas of boggy ground in the south-east into productive farmland by draining it of water and salt. This was directed out to sea rather than into the Coorong (an estuarine coastal lagoon) where it had previously trickled. The substantially reduced runoff into the Coorong has had a very deleterious effect on its health.
Advertisement
An additional issue is that, whereas evaporation from the Lower Lakes would once have been a mixture of fresh water and seawater, the barrages ensure it remains entirely fresh. This is estimated to be about 900 GL of water a year, worth $2-3bn at typical water trading prices. Most of it originates from rural communities in Victoria and NSW, including Deniliquin.
There are a few aspects about the Murray Darling Basin Plan that are worth preserving, in particular the creation of a water trading market. However, much of it needs to change.
Obviously, the South Australian government should demolish the barrages and allow the Murray to flow free to the sea. This would reinvigorate the Lower Lakes and keep the Murray mouth open while reducing the loss of fresh water to evaporation.
To protect Adelaide's water supply in drought years, it needs to build a weir across the Murray near Wellington. To restore the Coorong, it should commence a program of returning south-east drainage water to it.
Most importantly, water buybacks should cease. Moreover, the Commonwealth Environmental Water Holder should sell a considerable amount of the water it holds to farmers, to use in productive agriculture. And as for the environment, it's time its health was assessed by objective, measurable criteria, not by politically motivated water targets.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
1 post so far.