In more mundane situations, courts across the world have routinely thrown out confessions which are demonstrably true (because they are corroborated by objective evidence) on the basis that they were only made because the criminals were beaten up.
The second common objection to torture is that we can never be sure that the suspect has the relevant information. If that’s the case, simply don’t torture - in the same way that we’re not permitted to shoot in self-defence until we’re sure that the proposed target is up to no good.
It is also contended that life saving torture will lead down the slippery slope of other cruel practices. This is an intellectually defeatist argument. It tries to move the debate from what is on the table (life-saving torture) to situations where torture is used for reasons of domination and punishment - which is never justifiable.
Advertisement
A further common argument against torture is that it is inhumane and undemocratic. These are not reasons - just displays of venting. There could be nothing more inhumane than doing nothing as innocent people are being tortured to death.
Fanatics who oppose torture in all cases are adopting their own form of extremism. It is well-intentioned, but extremism in all its manifestations can lead to catastrophic consequences. Cruelty that is motivated by misguided kindness, hurts no less.
In order for the anti-torture extremists to move from the base of the moral mountain they need to accept that sometimes the only way to deal with evil is to hurt it and that evil is not transmittable. In the end, we must always act in a manner which maximises net flourishing and inform our moral choices by reason, not reflexive emotion - that is the closest it comes to an absolute moral principle.
Agent Kiriakou concedes that it was a tough call deciding that Zubayday should be tortured. But in the end he reasoned that he could not forgive himself if the CIA didn’t use torture on a suspect and therefore didn’t get “the nugget of information, and there was an attack”.
If agents in Australia refused to torture a suspect when it was apparent that it was the only means possible to save innocent lives, I don’t think we could forgive them either.
Discuss in our Forums
See what other readers are saying about this article!
Click here to read & post comments.
49 posts so far.